Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Sparks Taylor Swift Feud Buzz Explained

Charli Xcx's surprise cameo on Saturday Night Live this past weekend sent fans into a frenzy, not just for her performance with Role Model, but for a seemingly innocent T-shirt that many Swifties immediately linked to an alleged beef with Taylor Swift. But is there really fire behind all that smoke?

TL;DR: Here's the Quick Breakdown

Charli XCX rocked a "Max's Kansas City" shirt during her October 11, 2025, appearance on SNL with musical guest Role Model, sparking immediate speculation among fans that it was a jab at Taylor Swift.
Role Model quickly clarified that Charli simply borrowed the shirt from him, and it actually refers to a legendary New York City nightclub, not Taylor Swift's fiancé Travis Kelce or the Kansas City Chiefs.
This incident reignites a long-simmering "feud" narrative between the two pop stars, fueled by fan interpretations of songs like Charli's "Sympathy Is a Knife" and Taylor's "Actually Romantic," though both artists have denied direct disses.

Stepping Out as Sally: Charli XCX Joins Role Model on Stage

Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Ignites Fan Theories About Taylor Swift Feud image 3

Picture this: It's Saturday, October 11, 2025. Amy Poehler is hosting Saturday Night Live, celebrating the show's incredible 50th anniversary. Musical guest Role Model (real name Tucker Pillsbury) is performing his hit track, "Sally, When the Wine Runs Out." If you're familiar with Role Model's live shows, you know this song comes with a special tradition: he brings a "Sally" out on stage to join him for a super fun, dance-filled bridge. Over time, everyone from Hilary Duff to Natalie Portman and Olivia Rodrigo has stepped into the role.

This time around, as the barn doors on the set swung open, none other than Charli XCX emerged, looking effortlessly cool in a leather miniskirt, shades, and a very specific T-shirt. And that's where the internet collectively lost its mind.

The "Max's Kansas City" Tee That Launched a Thousand Tweets

Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Ignites Fan Theories About Taylor Swift Feud image 4

The shirt Charli wore proudly displayed the words "Max's Kansas City." For many, especially on social media, this immediately screamed "Taylor Swift shade." Why? Because Taylor's fiancé, Travis Kelce, is the tight end for the Kansas City Chiefs. It felt like a direct, albeit subtle, dig at the 14-time Grammy winner, especially considering the ongoing buzz around their alleged rivalry.

Fans instantly connected the dots (or thought they did), with tweets and posts flooding in. "CHARLI ON SNL IN A KANSAS CITY SHIRT?!? THE GIRLIES ARE FIGHTING PUBLICLY," one user exclaimed. Another quoted a lyric from Swift's "Actually Romantic" – "The KC T-shirt… oh tiny chihuahua, you will be dealt with" – implying Charli had just thrown down the gauntlet.

Unpacking the Real Story Behind Charli's Iconic Shirt Choice

Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Ignites Fan Theories About Taylor Swift Feud image 5

Hold up, Swifties! Before you crown this the definitive start of Pop War III, there's a crucial detail that quickly surfaced. Role Model himself, Tucker Pillsbury, took to his Instagram Story to clear the air. Charli didn't bring the shirt herself; she actually borrowed it from him!

Eagle-eyed fans also pointed out that Role Model had worn the very same "Max's Kansas City" shirt during his SNL promos earlier in the week. Plus, the name "Max's Kansas City" isn't just a random reference to a football team. It's the name of a legendary New York City nightclub that was a hot spot from 1965 to 1981, known for hosting iconic acts like The Velvet Underground (who even recorded a live album there). Charli XCX has openly spoken about being a huge fan of The Velvet Underground and their frontman, Lou Reed, even teasing a desire to make a "Lou Reed-era" record herself.

And let's not forget Role Model's own album, titled Kansas Anymore. The shirt could easily be a nod to his own work, making Charli's choice a friendly show of support for her fellow musician rather than a calculated diss. Sometimes, a shirt is just a shirt, borrowed from a friend.

A Deep Dive into the Alleged Musical Back-and-Forth

Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Ignites Fan Theories About Taylor Swift Feud image 6

Even if the shirt wasn't a direct diss, the timing of Charli's appearance stirred the pot. The "feud" rumors between Charli XCX and Taylor Swift have been swirling for a while, particularly intensified by recent song releases.

Tracing the Roots of the Rumored Rivalry Through Their Music

Fans first speculated about tension when Charli XCX released her 2024 album, Brat, featuring the track "Sympathy Is a Knife." Lyrics like "Don't wanna see her backstage at my boyfriend's show" immediately got people wondering if she was talking about Swift, given Charli's marriage to George Daniel (drummer for The 1975) and Swift's past relationship with Matty Healy (The 1975's frontman).

Charli, however, quickly shut down the speculation. She told New York Magazine that the song wasn't about anyone in particular: "That song is about me and my feelings and my anxiety and the way my brain creates narratives and stories in my head when I feel insecure and how I don’t want to be in those situations physically when I feel self-doubt."

Then came Taylor Swift's 12th studio album, The Life of a Showgirl, which dropped on October 3, 2025. On it was "Actually Romantic," a song many listeners believe is Swift's response to Charli. The lyrics definitely raise eyebrows:

"I heard you call me 'Boring Barbie' when the coke's got you brave / High-fived my ex and said you're glad he ghosted me."

"Wrote me a song saying it makes you sick to see my face / Some people might be offended. But it's actually sweet / All the time you've spent on me / It's honestly wild / All the effort you've put in."

— Taylor Swift, "Actually Romantic"

Ouch. These lines seem to reference Charli's past comments about her "Reputation" tour experience (where Charli opened for Swift in 2018, describing it as "waving to 5-year-olds") and her openness about drug use in her music, as well as the Matty Healy connection.

Taylor Swift's Candid Take on "Actually Romantic" and the "Love Letter" Concept

Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Ignites Fan Theories About Taylor Swift Feud image 7

During her "Release Party of a Showgirl" event, Taylor Swift offered her own interpretation of "Actually Romantic," framing it in a way that, while not naming names, certainly fit the ongoing narrative:

"The song 'Actually Romantic' is sort of a love letter to someone who hates you... It's about realizing that someone else has kind of had a one-sided, adversarial relationship with you that you didn't know about. And all of a sudden they start doing too much and they start letting you know that actually, you've been living in their head rent-free and you had no idea."

"It's presenting itself as them sort of resenting you or having a problem with you, but taking it and you just accept that as love and you accept it as attention and affection... And how flattering that somebody has made you such a big part of their reality when you didn't even think about this. It's actually pretty romantic if you really think about it."

— Taylor Swift on "Actually Romantic"

Swift's explanation suggests a sense of detached amusement, implying that any negative attention still counts as "attention" and "affection" in the industry. It's a savvy way to address perceived slights without directly engaging in a public spat.

Interestingly, despite all this, Taylor Swift has also previously praised Charli's 2024 album Brat, calling her writing "surreal and inventive," and was even seen dancing to Charli's 2025 Grammys performance in February. So, the relationship (or lack thereof) is definitely more complicated than a simple "feud."

Getting to Know Role Model: The Man Behind the "Sally" Sensation

Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Ignites Fan Theories About Taylor Swift Feud image 8

While all eyes were on Charli's shirt, let's not forget the reason she was on stage! Role Model, whose real name is Tucker Pillsbury, is a 28-year-old singer-songwriter who made his SNL debut that night. He's built a massive following thanks to his viral hit "Sally, When the Wine Runs Out," and his charming live performances where he invites a "Sally" to join him.

Tucker's journey in music started while recovering from injuries in college. He moved from rap experiments to his signature melodic pop sound, catching the attention of Mac Miller in 2017 with his ballad "Stolen Car." He's since released two albums: Rx in 2022 and Kansas Anymore in 2024 (with a deluxe edition, Kansas Anymore (The Longest Goodbye), dropping this year). Fun fact: Kansas Anymore was inspired by his breakup with ex Emma Chamberlain.

Beyond music, Role Model is also stepping into acting, with a role in Lena Dunham's upcoming movie Good Sex alongside Natalie Portman. His SNL appearance, featuring Charli XCX, was a major moment, amplifying his unique "Sally" tradition to a national audience.

So, Was It a Diss or Just a Coincidence? You Decide!

Charli XCX's SNL Shirt Ignites Fan Theories About Taylor Swift Feud image 9

In the end, Charli XCX's "Max's Kansas City" shirt on SNL is a perfect example of how quickly pop culture moments can be interpreted and reinterpreted online. While Role Model's explanation and the club's history suggest it was an innocent, perhaps even a supportive, gesture, the ongoing "feud" narrative between Charli and Taylor made it ripe for speculation.

Whether it was a subtle wink, a clever coincidence, or simply Charli borrowing a cool shirt from a friend, one thing's for sure: it got everyone talking. And in the world of pop music, sometimes, that's all that matters!

Frequently Asked Questions About Charli XCX's SNL Appearance

What is "Max's Kansas City"?

"Max's Kansas City" was a famous nightclub and music venue in New York City, open from 1965 to 1981. It was a hub for artists, musicians, and writers, and even hosted legendary bands like The Velvet Underground, who recorded a live album there. It has no direct connection to the Kansas City Chiefs football team.

Who is Role Model and what is his song "Sally, When the Wine Runs Out"?

Role Model is the stage name of Tucker Pillsbury, a 28-year-old American singer-songwriter. "Sally, When the Wine Runs Out" is one of his hit singles. During live performances of this song, Role Model has a tradition of bringing a guest, referred to as "Sally," onto the stage to dance and interact during a specific part of the track. Many celebrities and fans have participated in this viral moment.

What songs are supposedly about the Charli XCX and Taylor Swift feud?

Fans speculate that Charli XCX's 2024 song "Sympathy Is a Knife" from her album Brat is about Taylor Swift. Conversely, many believe Taylor Swift's 2025 song "Actually Romantic" from her album The Life of a Showgirl is a response to Charli XCX. Both artists have publicly denied that their songs are direct diss tracks aimed at each other.

When did Charli XCX appear on SNL?

Charli XCX made a surprise cameo on Saturday Night Live on October 11, 2025, during the show's 51st season. She appeared as the "Sally" guest during Role Model's performance of "Sally, When the Wine Runs Out."

Sources