Aubrey Plaza & Amy Poehler Bring the Heat in SNL's "Hunting Wives" Parody Extravaganza

Aubrey Plaza reunited with her Parks and Recreation co-star Amy Poehler on Saturday Night Live for a truly wild parody of Netflix's hit drama "The Hunting Wives," imagining a very steamy (and very gay) Season 2.

TL;DR

• Aubrey Plaza made a surprise, hilarious appearance in an SNL sketch, parodying the much-talked-about Netflix series, "The Hunting Wives."
• The sketch featured host Amy Poehler and Chloe Fineman in a fake trailer for a hypothetical "straight but lesbian horny Republican murder drama" Season 2.
• The actual cast of "The Hunting Wives" (Malin Akerman, Katie Lowes, Jaime Ray Newman) and novelist May Cobb loved the parody, even extending an open invitation for Plaza to join the real Season 2!

Diving Headfirst into the Wild World of "The Hunting Wives" on SNL

Alright, folks, if you've been anywhere near social media or, you know, just paying attention to what's fun on TV, you've probably heard about "The Hunting Wives." It's that Netflix show based on May Cobb's bestselling novel that everyone's been binging. And this past weekend, Saturday Night Live decided to give it the ultimate comedic treatment, with a twist that had everyone cheering: the iconic Aubrey Plaza showed up!

The sketch, hosted by the one and only Amy Poehler, plunged us straight into a fake trailer for "The Hunting Wives" Season 2. And let's just say, SNL absolutely nailed the vibe. They described the show as "the straight but lesbian horny Republican murder drama." If that doesn't hook you, I don't know what will!

Exploring the Steamy Shenanigans of a Hypothetical Second Season

The parody didn't hold back, kicking off with Amy Poehler, stepping into Malin Akerman's Margo role, making quite the entrance. She even recreated Margo's infamous "Look what the cat dragged in" line, adding a comedic flash that set the tone immediately. Poehler's Margo, alongside Chloe Fineman's Sophie (playing Brittany Snow's character), quickly found themselves entangled in some seriously erotic situations, perfectly lampooning the show's intense, sensual atmosphere.

The narrator, with deadpan perfection, promised that in this hypothetical Season 2, "Thighs will be squeezed" and "guns will be drawn." We saw Poehler's Margo giving Fineman's Sophie a "hands-on" lesson in margarita making that was less about mixology and more about, well, chemistry. It was pure comedic gold, exaggerating the show's already high-stakes, flirtatious dynamics.

But SNL wasn't just poking fun; they were also delivering some surprisingly sharp commentary. The fake critic quotes were hilariously specific, like "It's like Call Me by Your Name for women who shop at Bass Pro Shop" and "It's like if The L Word took place in Yellowstone. This show has healed our nation." These lines perfectly encapsulated the show's unique blend of high-octane drama, sexual tension, and a very particular kind of Southern charm, all while acknowledging its unexpected cultural impact.

Aubrey Plaza's Scene-Stealing Entrance and the Unexpected Twist

Then, the moment everyone was waiting for! Enter Aubrey Plaza, making a surprise appearance as the "new new girl" who's just moved to town from California. If you're a fan of Plaza, you know she has this incredible knack for playing characters who are equal parts alluring, mysterious, and a little bit unhinged. She fit right into the "Hunting Wives" universe like a glove, instantly raising the comedic (and tension) stakes.

Initially, the ladies welcomed her with suspiciously open arms, their flirtations dialed up to eleven. But the sketch saved its most biting, hilarious punchline for last. When they discovered Plaza's character identifies as gay, the entire mood shifted dramatically. The Texas housewives, who moments before were practically falling over themselves, recoiled in horror, pulling out their rifles with a collective gasp of "This is Texas!" It was a perfectly executed, stinging joke that highlighted the absurdity of certain cultural hypocrisies within the show's setting.

Plaza's delivery of lines like, "I don't have a boyfriend, I have a girlfriend," was absolutely spot-on, cementing her role as the ultimate deadpan queen. Her reunion with Poehler, her former co-star from Parks and Recreation, was a treat for fans, bringing their unique comedic energy back to the screen.

The Real Hunting Wives Cast and Creator Share Their Joyful Reactions

You know a parody hits different when the original cast loves it just as much as the fans! The real "Hunting Wives" actresses — Malin Akerman (Margo), Katie Lowes (Jill), and Jaime Ray Newman (Callie) — were absolutely thrilled by SNL's take. They even posted a video of themselves watching the sketch backstage at the 35th EMA Awards Gala, laughing and reacting intensely to Plaza's arrival and the sketch's escalating humor.

Their reaction video ended with an amazing open invitation to Aubrey Plaza: "Come play with us!" Can you imagine if this parody actually led to Plaza joining the actual "The Hunting Wives" Season 2? The internet would simply break.

Even May Cobb, the talented author behind the original psychological thriller novel, got in on the excitement. She shared the SNL video on her Instagram Stories, linking to articles about the sketch, clearly delighted by the high-profile comedic shout-out from legends like Poehler and Plaza.

"I’m so excited to write these amazing characters again, and I can’t wait to take the audience on another sexy, twisted, batshit crazy ride through Maple Brook."

— Rebecca Cutter, "The Hunting Wives" Series Creator

Fans Celebrate the Sapphic and Comedic Gold

It's safe to say the "girls, gays, and theys" of social media absolutely exploded with joy over the sketch. Fans poured onto platforms like X (formerly Twitter) to share their reactions, praising everything from Plaza's "lezzy" appearance to the full-circle moment of her reuniting with Poehler.

• One fan, @AFRA1DOFHE1GHTS, simply posted, "aubrey plaza lezzing out on snl thank god."
• @fsmoakbett observed, "i don’t think the sapphic community would survive if aubrey plaza joined season 2 of the hunting wives," a sentiment many likely echoed.
• Another, @knopeswifts, reflected on the "aubrey on amy’s snl, love history repeating itself" aspect, highlighting the beloved dynamic between the two stars.
• @qveenryder hilariously ran the numbers: "if i had a nickel every time aubrey plaza was lezzing out on snl, i’d have two nickels, which isn’t a lot but it’s amazing how it happened twice. #SNL."
• And the general consensus, as summed up by @creativlyblind, was: "AUBREY PLAZA IS SO PRETTY I CANT TAKE IT ANYMORE."

The sketch clearly resonated, not just for its sharp humor but also for its embrace of queer themes and the powerful comedic presence of two beloved actresses.

What You Need to Know About the Actual "The Hunting Wives" Season 2

So, while SNL's take on "The Hunting Wives" Season 2 was purely for laughs, here's the real deal: the actual Netflix series is indeed returning for a second season! Netflix officially announced the renewal back in September, much to the delight of its growing fanbase.

Creator Rebecca Cutter expressed her excitement about the show's return, promising an even wilder ride for viewers. She stated, "I’m so excited to write these amazing characters again, and I can’t wait to take the audience on another sexy, twisted, batshit crazy ride through Maple Brook." So get ready for more drama, more secrets, and undoubtedly more steamy moments when the real Season 2 eventually drops.

The SNL parody just goes to show how much of a cultural phenomenon "The Hunting Wives" has become, capturing audiences with its unique blend of Southern gothic drama and thrilling mystery.

Where to Catch All the Hunting Wives Action (Real and Parodied!)

Ready to jump into the scandalous world of "The Hunting Wives" or re-watch the hilarious SNL sketch? Here's where you can find them:

• "The Hunting Wives" Season 1: You can stream all the episodes of the original drama on Netflix right now.
• SNL's "The Hunting Wives" Parody Sketch: The episode featuring Aubrey Plaza and Amy Poehler aired on October 11, 2025 (or October 12, 2025, depending on your time zone) and can be streamed on Peacock. You can also find clips of the sketch on SNL's official social media channels.

Whether you're after the genuine thrills of the Netflix series or the belly laughs from SNL's brilliant send-up, there's plenty of "Hunting Wives" content to keep you entertained. And who knows, maybe that open invitation from the real cast to Aubrey Plaza will spark some real-life magic for Season 2!

Frequently Asked Questions About "The Hunting Wives" & SNL Parody Is "The Hunting Wives" Season 2 actually happening on Netflix?

Yes, good news! Netflix officially renewed "The Hunting Wives" for a second season in September. The SNL sketch was a comedic parody imagining what that season might look like, but the real one is definitely on its way.

Where can I watch the SNL sketch featuring Aubrey Plaza and Amy Poehler?

You can stream the full episode of Saturday Night Live from October 11/12, 2025, on Peacock. Clips of the "Hunting Wives" parody are also available on SNL's official social media accounts, including their X (Twitter) page.

What is "The Hunting Wives" about?

Based on May Cobb's novel, "The Hunting Wives" is a psychological thriller series on Netflix. It follows a group of wealthy socialites in Texas, exploring their lives filled with "sex, lies, and loaded guns," and quickly delves into a murder mystery. The SNL sketch hilariously described it as a "straight but lesbian horny Republican murder drama."

Who are the main cast members of the actual "The Hunting Wives" series?

The core cast of the Netflix series includes Malin Akerman as Margo Banks, Katie Lowes as Jill, Jaime Ray Newman as Callie, and Brittany Snow as Sophie O'Neil. The SNL sketch had Amy Poehler and Chloe Fineman parodying some of these roles.

Sources

• Based on recent news articles from October 11-12, 2025, regarding the "Saturday Night Live" episode featuring Amy Poehler and Aubrey Plaza, and the Netflix series "The Hunting Wives."