Robert Pattinson & Jennifer Lawrence Get Candid on Twilight, Hunger Games & Beyond

In a hilarious and surprising lie detector test, Robert Pattinson discovered Jennifer Lawrence almost joined the Twilight universe, leading to a fun debate about the biggest YA franchises and their potential returns.

TL;DR

• Jennifer Lawrence once auditioned for Twilight, a fact that genuinely shocked Robert Pattinson.
• Both stars expressed openness to reprising their iconic YA roles, with Pattinson having specific conditions for a Twilight return and Lawrence enthusiastically saying "100 percent" to Katniss.
• Their new film, Die My Love, showcases their undeniable chemistry and explores the challenging themes of postpartum depression.

When Bella Swan Almost Met Katniss Everdeen: A Shocking Revelation

Imagine a world where Katniss Everdeen, the fierce Mockingjay of Panem, was almost... Bella Swan, the brooding human torn between a vampire and a werewolf. This alternate cinematic reality nearly came to be, and even Robert Pattinson, the original Edward Cullen, couldn't believe it. During a recent Vanity Fair Lie Detector Test alongside his Die My Love co-star Jennifer Lawrence, Pattinson dropped a bombshell question: "You famously once auditioned for Twilight?" Lawrence's simple "Yeah, I auditioned for Twilight" was met with pure disbelief from Pattinson.

It’s a fun piece of movie trivia that highlights how many paths actors take before hitting it big. Lawrence, who would go on to win an Oscar and become an A-list star after her role in The Hunger Games, confidently stated she had "no" regrets about not booking the part of Bella Swan, which ultimately went to Kristen Stewart. It’s a testament to her journey and the successful career she carved out.

The Ultimate YA Showdown: Is Hunger Games Cooler Than Twilight?

The conversation inevitably turned to the long-standing debate that divided a generation of young adult fiction fans: Is The Hunger Games cooler than Twilight? Pattinson, ever the provocateur, directly asked Lawrence this very question. Her response? A seemingly truthful "no," according to the lie detector examiner. However, Lawrence quickly joked, "Breaking news: This machine is broken," and later admitted to telling multiple lies during the interview, leaving fans to playfully speculate on her true allegiance.

This playful exchange highlights the enduring cultural impact of both franchises. Twilight, with Pattinson as the sparkly vampire Edward Cullen, soared to popularity between 2008 and 2012, making him and Kristen Stewart household names. Its five films collectively grossed over $3.3 billion worldwide. The Hunger Games, kicking off in 2012 with Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen, similarly catapulted her to international stardom, cementing the YA dystopian genre's place in Hollywood.

"Oh, yeah, for sure. I like taking jobs off younger actors. I do. I want to play 17 Again."

— Robert Pattinson on returning to Twilight, per FandomWire

Returning to Iconic Roles: Edward Cullen and Katniss Everdeen's Potential Comebacks

The nostalgia train didn't stop at auditions and debates. Both actors were asked about revisiting their career-defining roles. Robert Pattinson, reflecting on Twilight's 20th anniversary (the first book was released on October 5, 2005), expressed a surprising openness to returning as Edward Cullen. He told TheWrap, "I can’t believe the cultural legs that movie has had… just mind-blowing to me. It’s so cool." When specifically asked if he’d return for a new Twilight film if directed by the Safdie brothers (with whom he collaborated on Good Time), he enthusiastically replied, "Oh, yeah, for sure." He even quipped about enjoying "taking jobs off younger actors" and wanting to "play 17 again."

This willingness marks a shift from his earlier, sometimes critical views of the franchise, which he once described as a "sexual fantasy" during the initial press run. But time, it seems, heals all wounds—or at least adds a layer of appreciative perspective. Lionsgate, who acquired Summit Entertainment (the original studio), has already re-released the entire Twilight Saga in cinemas in October and November 2025 for the anniversary and has an animated series based on Midnight Sun, titled Midnight Suns, in development at Netflix, signaling their continued interest in expanding the universe.

Meanwhile, Jennifer Lawrence also addressed her future with The Hunger Games. She confirmed she enjoyed the recent prequel, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes (released November 17, 2023), and humbly acknowledged that Rachel Zegler's version of "The Hanging Tree" was superior to her own. The good news for fans? When asked by Variety in 2023 if she’d be interested in reprising Katniss, Lawrence declared, "Oh, my God — totally! If Katniss could ever come back into my life, 100 percent."

This fervent desire comes at an interesting time. Author Suzanne Collins has penned another prequel, Sunrise on the Reaping, focusing on Haymitch Abernathy's 50th Hunger Games, set for publication in March 2025. Lionsgate has already confirmed a movie adaptation for November 20, 2026. While the main story predates Katniss, there's a possibility for an epilogue featuring an older Haymitch with Katniss and Peeta. Josh Hutcherson has expressed interest in returning, though nothing is confirmed. The door for the original trio to potentially make a cameo appears to be open.

A Deep Connection on Their New Project: Die My Love

Beyond the nostalgic discussions, Pattinson and Lawrence recently joined forces for the psychological thriller Die My Love, which hit cinemas in early November 2025. The film follows a young mother (Lawrence) grappling with postpartum depression and psychosis, with Pattinson playing her partner. Both actors received high praise for their performances, with NME calling it an "excellent film."

Their on-screen chemistry, as evidenced by their banter in the lie detector test, stems from a genuine off-screen connection. Pattinson told Extra that they "had very similar life experiences even though we didn't know each other at all before this." As new parents themselves, this shared experience deeply impacted their approach to the film. Pattinson noted, "the babies [in the film] were exactly the same age as my daughter," making him more invested in discussions about baby milestones with the on-set parents than ever before. This real-world relatability undoubtedly added depth to their portrayals.

The Nuance of Truth: More Than Just a "No"

While the lie detector test provided definitive "truths" and "lies," the context of these interviews is crucial. Lawrence's immediate quip about the machine being "broken" after denying Hunger Games was "cooler" than Twilight, coupled with her later admission of general interview fibs, suggests a playful evasion rather than a definitive judgment. Similarly, Pattinson's enthusiastic "for sure" about a Twilight return is tempered by his specific condition (Safdie brothers) and lighthearted jokes about his age. He's actually a 39-year-old millennial, not Gen Z as he humorously claimed during the test!

This playful dynamic demonstrates that while actors participate in these fun segments, their answers often carry layers of humor and context. It’s less about absolute truth and more about entertaining fans and promoting their current projects.

Practical Takeaways for Fans

• Catch Die My Love: If you're looking for an intense, critically acclaimed drama with stellar performances, their new film is in theaters now.
• Stay Tuned for YA Revivals: Both Twilight and Hunger Games universes are actively expanding, and there's a real chance your favorite stars could pop up in future installments.
• Revisit the Classics: With Twilight's 20th anniversary and re-releases, it's a perfect time to rewatch the original films and re-engage with the debate.
• Don't Take Lie Detectors Too Seriously: Remember, celebrity interviews are often a blend of candor and playful performance!

FAQ: All About Die My Love & The YA Franchises

When did Die My Love release? Die My Love was released in cinemas in early November 2025 (specific dates vary slightly by region, either November 7 or November 14). What is Die My Love about? It's a psychological thriller about a new mother (Jennifer Lawrence) experiencing postpartum depression and psychosis, and its impact on her partner (Robert Pattinson). Will Jennifer Lawrence return as Katniss Everdeen? She has expressed strong interest, saying "100 percent." There's a possibility of a cameo in the upcoming Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping movie, slated for November 20, 2026. Is Robert Pattinson serious about returning to Twilight? He said "for sure" if the Safdie brothers direct it and joked about "taking jobs from younger actors," indicating his interest is tied to specific creative conditions and a playful attitude.

Sources

• TheWrap, "Robert Pattinson Asks Jennifer Lawrence Point-Blank If She Thinks ‘Hunger Games’ Is ‘Cooler’ Than ‘Twilight’ | Video," November 8, 2025.
• Vanity Fair, "JLaw and R.Pat Are One Delightful Duo," November 8, 2025.
• ScreenRant, "Jennifer Lawrence Finally Gives Verdict On The Hunger Games Prequel," November 8, 2025.
• Far Out Magazine, "Robert Pattinson open to ‘Twilight’ franchise reboot: “For sure”," November 8, 2025.
• FandomWire, "Robert Pattinson Wants to Return to Twilight Under One Condition," November 8, 2025.
• CinemaBlend, "Robert Pattinson Finally Weighs In On If He’d Return To Twilight After Jennifer Lawrence Asked Him A Question While Hooked Up To A Lie Detector," November 8, 2025.
• Geo.tv, "Jennifer Lawrence recalls rare history with Robert Pattinson's 'Twilight'," November 9, 2025.
• Extra, "Robert Pattinson on Bonding with Jennifer Lawrence as New Parents (Exclusive)," November 7, 2025.
• NME, "Robert Pattinson gets asked about ‘Twilight’ every day: “It’s just mind-blowing to me”," November 5, 2025.
• Pajiba, "Robert Pattinson Asked Jennifer Lawrence the Big Question," November 8, 2025.