A24's Eternity: Olsen, Teller, Turner in Afterlife Love Triangle

A24 just dropped new trailers for Eternity, a romantic fantasy starring Elizabeth Olsen, Miles Teller, and Callum Turner that puts a unique spin on the afterlife. Get ready for some serious feels this Thanksgiving season!

TL;DR: Quick Bites on A24's 'Eternity'

Elizabeth Olsen stars in A24's Eternity, where her character must make an impossible choice between two loves in the afterlife.
Miles Teller plays her husband, while Callum Turner is her first love, setting up a truly unique and emotional romantic dilemma.
Directed by David Freyne, this "tender, funny, and beautifully bittersweet" film is slated to hit theaters nationwide in late November 2025.

If there's one studio that consistently delivers films that stick with you long after the credits roll, it's A24. From mind-bending sci-fi epics to deeply human dramas, they always seem to find stories that spark conversation and challenge expectations. Their latest offering, Eternity, is no exception, promising a romantic fantasy that's equal parts whimsical and thought-provoking. Imagine getting to the afterlife and being told you have to choose who you spend the rest of forever with? That's the wild ride Elizabeth Olsen's character, Joan, is on, caught between two incredible loves played by Miles Teller and Callum Turner. This movie isn't just about what happens after you die; it's about what defines love, connection, and choice, even when time loses all meaning.

Exploring the Ultimate Afterlife Dilemma: A Week to Choose Forever

Forget pearly gates or fiery pits; David Freyne’s Eternity presents an afterlife that’s more like a cosmic waiting room with a ticking clock. Seriously, souls arriving in this liminal space get just one week to pick their eternal companion, and with that choice, their destiny. For Joan, played with what promises to be raw vulnerability by Elizabeth Olsen, this isn't some abstract philosophical exercise. She's fresh off her mortal coil, only to find herself staring down a choice between two men who profoundly held her heart.

On one side is Larry (Miles Teller), her devoted husband who shared her life, built a home with her, and walked alongside her through all her earthly years. On the other is Luke (Callum Turner), her first love, whose life was tragically cut short by war decades ago. The kicker? He's literally been waiting for her to arrive, making his sudden reappearance both incredibly romantic and, let's be honest, incredibly awkward! This isn't your grandma's vision of the great beyond; it’s a deeply personal, emotionally intricate space where past and present collide in the most profound way. It’s a concept that immediately brings to mind Albert Brooks' classic Defending Your Life, but with a unique, heartbreaking romantic twist that only A24 could pull off.

The premise alone sets the stage for a whirlwind of emotions. How do you quantify a lifetime of shared memories against the burning embers of a first love that never got the chance to fully blossom? The film promises to delve deep into these unanswerable questions, using the fantastical setting to explore very real human dilemmas about regret, longing, and the true meaning of commitment. It’s about more than just picking a partner; it’s about choosing a chapter of your existence to truly live in, forever.

Elizabeth Olsen Anchors a Truly Heart-Wrenching Performance

Elizabeth Olsen Faces an Eternal Love Triangle in A24's 'Eternity' image 3

Elizabeth Olsen has definitely carved out a niche for herself in roles that demand serious emotional heavy lifting, and Eternity looks like it’s tailor-made for her immense talents. Whether she’s battling cosmic threats and processing intense grief as Wanda Maximoff in Marvel’s WandaVision or navigating true-crime dramas with unsettling precision in Love & Death, Olsen consistently brings a grounded intensity and profound vulnerability to her characters. As Joan, she's expected to deliver a performance that perfectly captures the confusion, the lingering grief, and the impossible tenderness of being torn between two unfinished loves.

The trailers give us tantalizing glimpses of Olsen's incredible range, showing her quiet disbelief at her bizarre situation, the undeniable spark and renewed intimacy with Luke, and the complicated comfort of rediscovering Larry under these bizarre new cosmic rules. Her portrayal of Joan promises to be both incredibly human and ethereal, conveying a kind of enduring heartbreak and indecision that transcends mortality itself. Get ready to have your own heartstrings pulled, because Olsen is set to make Joan’s dilemma feel incredibly real and deeply personal, forcing us to consider our own emotional landscapes.

Her ability to convey complex inner turmoil with subtle expressions and nuanced dialogue will be crucial in making this fantastical premise believable. It’s clear that Joan’s journey isn’t just about making a choice, but about understanding the different facets of love she’s experienced and reconciling them within herself. This role seems poised to be another standout for Olsen, further solidifying her reputation as an actress capable of anchoring films with deep emotional gravity.

Miles Teller and Callum Turner: A Battle of Enduring Love Versus First Love

Elizabeth Olsen Faces an Eternal Love Triangle in A24's 'Eternity' image 4

At the beating heart of Eternity is this absolutely captivating and emotionally charged love triangle. On one side, we have Miles Teller as Larry. After stealing scenes in blockbusters like Top Gun: Maverick and earning critical praise for his nuanced performance in The Offer, Teller brings a relatable sincerity and grounded strength to the screen. His character, Larry, embodies the kind of steady, mature love that builds a life, brick by emotional brick. He’s the husband, the steadfast partner, the one who saw Joan through her entire earthly journey.

Teller’s natural ability to convey authenticity and quiet strength will undoubtedly make Larry’s struggle to hold onto his wife, even in the eternal plane, deeply poignant and understandable. His love represents the comfort of the familiar and the power of shared history. Then there's Callum Turner as Luke, Joan's first love. Known for his compelling work in films like The Boys in the Boat and the Fantastic Beasts series, Turner brings a magnetic, almost wistful charm to Luke. He’s the embodiment of that intense, never-fading first love, a connection so pure it was cut short too soon, who has literally waited decades for Joan to arrive. His presence in the afterlife represents the road not taken, the passionate spark that remains untarnished by the daily grind of life.

The trailers tease an undeniable, powerful chemistry between Olsen, Teller, and Turner, making Joan's choice not just a pivotal plot point but a genuine, agonizing emotional journey for both her and the audience. It’s a beautifully bittersweet dynamic that explores how different kinds of love shape us, and which kind ultimately defines our forever. Each actor brings a distinct energy that makes Joan’s dilemma incredibly compelling, forcing us to empathize with her impossible situation.

"It will give you all the feels."

Joey Magidson, Awards Radar Editor

David Freyne's Unique Direction and Vision for the Afterlife Narrative

Elizabeth Olsen Faces an Eternal Love Triangle in A24's 'Eternity' image 5

Behind the lens, Irish writer-filmmaker David Freyne brings his distinctive and thoughtful vision to Eternity. Freyne, known for his emotionally charged and often socially resonant films like The Cured (a compelling take on a post-zombie epidemic society) and the charming LGBTQ+ coming-of-age story Dating Amber, approaches the afterlife not as a grand, CGI-heavy spectacle, but as an intimate, contemplative crossroads. He co-wrote the screenplay with Pat Cunnane, whose original script even landed on the prestigious 2022 Black List, a list of Hollywood's most-liked unproduced screenplays, signaling its unique appeal and strong narrative.

Freyne’s interpretation largely strips away the typical religious dogma or fantastical tropes, instead focusing on the very human aspects of choice, regret, longing, and what it truly means to be deeply connected to someone. The film’s tone is said to balance melancholia with moments of genuine humor and hope, hinting at a visual style that is both luminous and understated. It’s about reflecting on our past, making peace with our choices, and understanding the true weight of love, even when time itself is no longer a factor. Freyne's sensitive and introspective direction ensures that Eternity will resonate on a deeply personal level, asking us to ponder what we would do if given the same impossible decision, and making the afterlife feel surprisingly grounded in human experience.

His previous works demonstrate a knack for handling complex emotional landscapes and nuanced character relationships, which bodes incredibly well for a film like Eternity. It’s clear Freyne is interested in the human condition, regardless of the setting, and that intentional focus will undoubtedly make this film particularly powerful.

A24 Continues to Push Boundaries with Existential Narratives

Elizabeth Olsen Faces an Eternal Love Triangle in A24's 'Eternity' image 6

A24 has definitely carved out a revered niche as the go-to studio for films that dare to be different, often blending genres and challenging conventional storytelling. Think the multiversal mayhem of Everything Everywhere All at Once, the poignant, time-spanning romance of Past Lives, or the mythical, introspective journey of The Green Knight. Eternity fits right into this esteemed family of thought-provoking, genre-bending cinema, further cementing A24’s reputation for supporting unique directorial voices and compelling, character-driven narratives.

Instead of relying on over-the-top special effects or overt fantastical elements, A24 and Freyne consistently focus on the internal journey and emotional resonance, making the film feel incredibly relatable despite its otherworldly setting. The stellar supporting cast further enhances this human-first approach. Oscar winner Da’Vine Joy Randolph (fresh off her acclaimed role in The Holdovers) is sure to bring her signature warmth and emotional depth, while John Early and Olga Merediz (with a possible appearance by veteran actress Betty Buckley, as one source notes) are set to inject moments of much-needed levity and charm into the afterlife proceedings. This talented ensemble proves that even in the afterlife, human connection, a bit of humor, and plenty of heart are absolutely key to navigating eternity.

This commitment to authentic storytelling, even within a high-concept premise, is what makes A24 films resonate so deeply with audiences. Eternity looks set to be another example of their unique brand of cinematic art, blending philosophical inquiry with raw, relatable human emotion.

When and Where Can You Experience A24's 'Eternity'?

Elizabeth Olsen Faces an Eternal Love Triangle in A24's 'Eternity' image 7

So, when can you dive into Joan's existential love story and witness this truly unique romantic fantasy unfold? This is where things get a little tricky, as a couple of different dates have been reported for the film's release. Some initial reports indicated that Eternity would hit theaters on November 14th, 2025. However, other prominent sources, including one directly from A24's official trailer and several news outlets, state a nationwide release during Thanksgiving week, specifically November 26th, 2025.

It’s entirely possible that the earlier date of November 14th could be for a limited release in select cities, with the wider nationwide rollout planned to coincide with the busy holiday week, allowing more people to catch the film. For now, it’s safest to mark your calendars for late November 2025, particularly around Thanksgiving, to catch this highly anticipated film on the big screen. It’s definitely one you’ll want to experience in a theater, letting all those "feels" wash over you in a collective setting. As for streaming, don't hold your breath just yet; the film is currently marked as 'not yet available for streaming' – and A24 films often enjoy a respectable theatrical window before heading to digital platforms or subscription services. Keep an eye on official A24 channels for the most precise updates!

Eternity promises to be more than just a romantic movie; it's a poignant exploration of choices, regrets, and the enduring power of love beyond life itself. With Elizabeth Olsen leading a fantastic cast under David Freyne's sensitive direction, A24 looks set to deliver another cinematic gem that will make you think, feel, and maybe even re-evaluate your own cherished memories and connections. Get ready for a deeply affecting and utterly unique film experience this November!

Frequently Asked Questions About A24's 'Eternity'

Elizabeth Olsen Faces an Eternal Love Triangle in A24's 'Eternity' image 8

When does A24's Eternity come out in theaters? Eternity is expected to release nationwide in theaters around Thanksgiving week, specifically November 26th, 2025, though some reports also mention November 14th.

What is Eternity about? The film follows Joan (Elizabeth Olsen) in a unique afterlife setting where souls have one week to decide where they'll spend eternity. She is faced with the impossible choice between her husband Larry (Miles Teller) and her first love Luke (Callum Turner), who died young and has waited decades for her.

Who is in the main cast of Eternity? The movie stars Elizabeth Olsen as Joan, Miles Teller as Larry, and Callum Turner as Luke. The talented supporting cast includes Oscar winner Da'Vine Joy Randolph, John Early, and Olga Merediz.

Who directed Eternity? Eternity was directed by Irish writer and filmmaker David Freyne, who is known for his previous films The Cured and Dating Amber.